
Personnel:
Roger Wootten: acoustic guitar, lead vocals
Glenn Goring: guitars, hand drums, backing vocals
Bobbie Watson: lead and backing vocals, percussion
Colin Pearson: violin, viola
Andy Hellaby: bass, backing vocals
Rob Young: flute, oboe, hand drums
+ Lindsay Cooper: bassoon
+ Keith Hale: keyboards, synthesizer, marimba
+ Gordon Coxon: drums, percussion
+ Jon Seagroatt: flute, oboe, hand drums
Folk music, like blues, jazz, and rock, comes in many variations. One type of folk song are rural ballads. Others might be rural but take the form of “murder ballads.” The folk standard “Pretty Polly” is a fairly well-known rural murder ballad. It concerns a girl who is lured into a forest, murdered, then buried in a shallow grave. There are different interpretations (it’s folk, after all) but it was originally known as “The Gosport Tragedy” and dates to 1720s England. Everyone from Cincinnati, Ohio’s all-female Coon Creek Girls to Ireland’s Gilbert O’Sullivan has performed it. Bob Dylan used the music for his bleak “Ballad of Hollis Brown.”
Halloween is an ideal time to profile a band that put a twisted pagan spin on murder ballads. Comus is maybe the darkest folk group (progressive folk) ever to emerge from the British Isles. They began in Bromley, Kent in 1969 around art students Roger Wootten and Glenn Goring. The original incarnation made only one album, First Utterance. But original vinyl copies on the Dawn label are as sought-after as Beatles lunchboxes. Comus, however, never graced a lunchbox. And for good reason.
Those familiar with David Bowie‘s song, “Memory of a Free Festival” from his second album might know that it was inspired by an actual festival organized by an arts group, the Beckenham Arts Lab, curated in 1969 by Bowie with journalist Mary Finnegan. This arts collective may have been modeled after Andy Warhol’s Factory. It met regularly at a former folk club called The Three Tuns, located in the Beckenham section of South London.
One of the music acts developing their material at the Beckenham Arts Lab was Comus (name chosen by manager Chris Youle and inspired by Greek mythology and poet John Milton). Bowie must have been impressed with Comus because he chose them as support act on an early tour.

Although rooted in the English rural/murder ballad folk tradition, and citing Bert Jansch and John Renbourn as music influences, Comus was equally enamored with envelope-pushing Velvet Underground. (Maybe Velvets/Warhol disciple Bowie introduced them to the music.) First Utterance, with outer sleeve art by Wootten, inner by Goring, might best be called acoustic acid-folk, the guitars, violin, flute, and hand percussion creating an ominous world of black paganism. The songs were mainly written by Wootten (top left in above photo) while he was immersed in your standard 1960s “drug-induced haze.”
The best way I can describe First Utterance is this: Roger Chapman (Family) meets Gillie Smith (Gong) meets Ian Anderson‘s flute while in a facility for the criminally insane. Murder, rape, torture, mental illness, and necrophilia might be the kind of disturbing subjects that certain corners of our entertainment industry have discovered will titillate certain corners of the populace today. But in 1971 such subjects still caused consternation. (This was only two years after the Manson murders.) First Utterance cuts like “Drip Drip,” “Diana,” and “The Prisoner” make Black Sabbath sound like the Archies. I won’t reproduce any lyrics. Suffice to say, the images conjured are not for the squeamish. Maybe not for the non-squeamish. And musically, other than a few snatches of melody, First Utterance is a spooktacular ho-hum. Some nice acoustic guitar and flute here and there, and interesting ideas are suggested. But the ideas are never developed, and Wootten and Bobbie Watson‘s vocals, especially the former’s, are pretty atrocious. Atmosphere, there is. But even a cardboard box has atmosphere.
The record, not surprisingly for an album of repulsive themes issued on a tiny label, fell flat on release. Perhaps this is why the band scrapped their second utterance. The aborted second sessions featured noted bassoonist Lindsay Cooper (bottom left in photo above), who soon left Comus after getting an offer to join Henry Cow. (Definitely an upward move.) It then took two more years to finally release something, the more conventional and less shocking, To Keep from Crying (1974). Cooper appears only on the title cut, while Gong saxophonist Didier Malherbe helps out. The band itself considered this album a “disaster.”  Comus ultimately splintered. Wootten changed his surname to “Raven,” briefly lived in Sweden, and contributed to songs by Henry Cow brother band, Slapp Happy.
As often happens these days, it took a popular, successful music act to pull Comus from the abyss. In this case it was the Swedish prog-metal band, Opeth. The leader, Mikael à kerfeldt, evidently is a fan. (à kerfeldt’s earlier band had the delightful name of “Bloodbath.”) Because of à kerfeldt’s enthusiasm, Comus rose from the dead for a belated issue of some of their discarded second sessions, calling it Out of the Coma. New members were then enlisted for live appearances (see Personnel above), and the band also, somehow, despite its meager output, managed the obligatory cash-grabbing box set.

Though once an obscurity, Comus today is praised to the hilt by a niche of psych and prog collectors. Might this be reflective of our times? Has there been a numbing of sensitivities? My own feeling is that Wootten and company deliberately intended to shock as a way of countering some of the twee pastoral folk of the time, and distancing themselves from then-in-vogue “peace and love” vibes. Shock rock on a fast track. Wooten is quoted as saying, “The love and peace thing, it was very weak. It didn’t have any teeth, and you wanted to give it a kick.”Â
Certainly, some of the “love and peace thing” did lack “teeth.” But kicking pearly whites doesn’t necessarily translate into something better. The Velvet Underground countered those same peace/love vibes much earlier. But Uncle Lou didn’t do shock for the sake of shock. He wrote about people who were sad and tragic, many that he personally knew. And even Sister Ray wasn’t criminally insane. I guess what I’m trying to say is that I see little redeeming value in songs intended to shock about rape and (other things). And I guess we each set our own lines that shan’t be crossed.
I’ll stick with Black Sabbath this October 31. Happy Halloween.
EP
“Diana” / “In the Lost Queen’s Eyes” / “Winter is a Coloured Bird” (1971)
Albums
First Utterance (1971)
To Keep From Crying (1974)
Out of the Coma (2012)
Live Album
East of Sweden: Live at Melloboat Festival 2008 (2011)
Box Set
Song to Comus: The Complete Collection (2005)


































You must be logged in to post a comment.