Belly
(Copyright © 1999-2024 Piero Scaruffi | Terms of use )
Star , 7/10
King , 5/10
Tanya Donelly: Lovesongs For Underdogs , 5/10
Tanya Donelly: Beautysleep , 6/10
Tanya Donelly: Whiskey Range Ghost (2004) , 6/10 , 6/10
Links:

(Clicka qua per la versione Italiana)

(Translated from my original Italian text by Cinzia Russi)
Tanya Donelly, the twenty-six-year-old guitarist of the Throwing Muses and of the Breeders, started Belly in 1992.

Assembled with seasoned musicians of her hometown in Rhode Island, the band soon created quite a sensation with the EP Slow Dust (4AD, 1992). Dusted is the introduction to their vocal harmonies, charmingly threaded with whispers and echoes, lullabies and sighs, as well as the way they can combine them with mischievous riffs into voluptuous oriental dances. At the other end of the spectrum is the angelic ballad Dancing Gold. Another manifesto of their subtle art is Low Red Moon, a martial, psychedelic piece, which radiates a liturgical atmosphere, bathed in funereal organ and guitar chords, but at the same time wrapped in a tender melody, with Donelly aiming for Sinead O'Connor's guttural register. Slow Dog is another prodigy of their musical alchemy: the song seems to be suspended in a sort of unmelodious limbo, from where a sublime refrain suddenly springs, leading into a furious hard rock pace. Donelly, who in the past had been left in the background, is now the protagonist of these pop masterpieces, along with thirty-three-year-old bass player Gail Greenwood.

It is with the album STAR (Sire), released in 1993 and including the EP, that Donnelly can unbare her histrionic and polyedric persona- alternatively tender and aggressive, fragile and fatal - and give e free rein to her whims in a set of diverse and exhilarating songs, in harmonies which wed the exotic and the lysergic and which drown the most majestic melody in atmospheres of sheer nightmare. Angel, an Indian carnival a-la Rolling Stones' Paint It Black, is a masterpiece of this latter style; the song is sustained by a whirling rhythm and a hypnotic raga riff on which Donelly grafts her galactic trills. Her style also triumphs in the pop carillon of Gepetto, a most tender rigmarole, softly sung along a merry-go-round beat. Donelly's positive poetics dominates such juvenile jolly sarabands. The whole album is characterized by a subtle primitivism, a constant rejecting of the innovations it presents, content with its meaninglessness. Thus Someone To Die For, a sad elegy sung in a girlish tone, thus the sorcerous Witch, another composition characterized by a laconic arrangement, and the allegorical ballad Feed The Tree; but above all the sweetest lullaby Every Word. So much so that, in the end, one can no more tell whether gloomy reflections like Untogether and Stay, entirely at the mercy of anxious guitar strokes and phantasmagoric singing, are wise and conceited or childish and naive. They could be nothing but serenades that Donelly is addressing to herself, begging them to make love to her melancholy. Frail and moody, oneiric and enchanting, better than anything Throwing Muses ever did, this ethereal album launches Donelly as a mature female artist, who found out her womanhood in a rock band.

Within this introspective pop genre, Donelly is gifted with a refined musical sensibility that would become Kate Bush, even though her little songs are by no means colored by the symphonic and whimsical shades which are peculiar of the British singer.


(Translated from my original Italian text by ChatGPT and Piero Scaruffi)

The flop of King (Sire, 1995) was completely unexpected. The album is desolately bland, with Donelly hidden behind the trio accompanying her, firmly controlled by guitarist Thomas Gorman. Unfortunately, their sound is generic: with distortions abolished, it fails to build an identity beyond that of humble “session men.” Donelly’s voice, stronger and inclined to rise into a vibrato register, saves songs like Seal My Fate, which would otherwise be completely anonymous. The Belly aimed for a broad audience with drowsy melodies in gentle crescendo, like the waltz-paced Silverfish, the whispery Bees (which undergoes some evolutions worthy of Sinéad O’Connor), or the confessional Juliana Hatfield–like Puberty. The most convincing is Now They'll Sleep, the only one with a semblance of the adolescent exuberance that made the first record great, followed by Red, a slow song redeemed by a martial “Mexican” hiccup, and Untitled And Unsung, which advances with the mystery of the early Doors. The band regains a minimum of grit in the title track, but this time the melodies are missing. Having exited alternative rock, Donelly presented herself in the guise of a pop singer. The new songs suffer especially from excessive production, which weighs on them like a dense cluster of clouds.

Tanya Donelly debuted as a solo artist with the EP Sliding and Diving (Reprise, 1996), featuring Bum, Restless, Swoon, and Human, and then recorded the versatile Lovesongs For Underdogs (Reprise, 1997), surrounded by Boston friends (including her husband Dean Fisher, a collaborator of Juliana Hatfield). The album boasted the single Pretty Deep and a few catchy refrains (The Bright Light, Clipped, Manna, Goat Girl), but it was a disappointment since it presented neither a personal artist nor an original songwriter.


(Original English text by Piero Scaruffi)

Tanya Donelly's second album, Beautysleep (4AD, 2002), is the second best of her career after the first Belly album. Her voice has never been so strong and so sweet (as displayed on the suave The Storm, probably the standout, and on the haunting Moonbeam Monkey, virtually a duet with the ghost of Morphine's Mark Sandman). Her lyrics are a little awkward (rock stars are not exactly Shakespeare) and embarassingly personal (The Night You Saved My Life and Keeping You, dedicated to her baby, but both catchy like the best of Belly) Tasty arrangements enhance the atmospheric monologues of Life is but a Dream, Another Moment, Darkside, The Shadow. With the exception of Wrap-around Skirt, none is loud or aggressive. Each song radiates a sense of intimacy, and the album as a whole feels like a morbid peek into her domestic life.

Tanya Donelly's Whiskey Range Ghost (4AD, 2004) is a more spartan and humble collection in a style of intimate singer-songwriter a` la Tori Amos. The material is often impressive (Every Devil, My Life as a Ghost, The Promise, Butterfly Thing, Divine Sweet Divide) but a more intense arrangement would have been welcome.

Tanya Donelly's This Hungry Life (Eleven Thirty, 2007) was a live album.

What is unique about this music database