
(Photo from the Dominion Post) It took three and a half days to pick a jury for Jimmy's trial. Honestly, it's hard to imagine how they were able to pick a jury at all. My hometown -- the whole county -- is small. Everyone knows everyone else or at least knows something about everyone else. Of the original panel of 78 potential jurors, something like 21 people claimed to be related to the victims. Another dozen or so claimed to know Jimmy. Only a handful claimed to have no real knowledge of the case (and that I highly doubt).
When the case finally got underway, the defense presented its theory in its opening statement: self-defense. Jimmy asserted that he and Lori had been abusing pain pills, but that he wanted her to stop because she was pregnant. She had agreed to quit, but then that day, she went searching for pills. They argued. She locked herself and Collin in the bedroom and began making a phone call. Jimmy went to his computer and began to compose a letter to Lori, saying he could not do it anymore. He then went upstairs to talk to Lori, who emerged from the room in a rage and shoved him. Collin followed after her, and the three began down the stairs. Jimmy said she stopped on the stairs and shoved him again. She lost her balance, and he reached to grab her shirt. Lori came out of her shirt and fell down three or four stairs, hitting her head on the banister.
She became even more enraged when she found the letter on the computer. "What is this?" she screamed. She left the house, cell phone in hand and dialing 911. Jimmy followed after her as she went out to the van where Jimmy had a shotgun he had hoped to take to Lori's father for repair. Jimmy took the cell phone from Lori and disconnected the call. Lori then pulled out the shotgun, and the two fought over it. Collin was shot in the process. As Collin lay on the ground with a gaping wound in his stomach, Jimmy went back into the house to call for help. Lori followed him into the basement, gun in hand and shouting, "Look what you did!" Jimmy picked up a ball bat and struck Lori in the head. He only remembers hitting her once, but knows, from looking at the photos, that he must have hit her more than once.
As she lay lifeless on the basement floor, Jimmy went back outside to check on Collin. When he found Collin dead, he was grief-stricken. For reasons he cannot explain, he picked up a nearby rock and bashed Collin in the head.
Realizing that his ex-wife would soon be dropping off their children, Jimmy wrapped the bodies up, put them in Lori's Explorer, and drove the vehicle to the back of his property. He then quickly attempted to clean up the scene. He met his ex-wife at the bottom of the driveway and took the kids. He drove to his aunt and uncle's home and confessed to his uncle Jan what he had done. He asked Jan to help him hide the bodies, but Jan said that he could not and would not. Jimmy took the kids and left. Jan told his wife, Roxanne, who called Jan's brother, Jack. It was Jack who called 911 and said, "I hope he's talking out of his ass, but he seemed serious.... Oh God."
Jack, Jan, and Roxanne then drove to the house to get the kids. The police were there. Roxanne went in to get the kids and to sit with Jimmy who seemed, she said, completely unlike himself, like a caged animal. He was angry that they had called the police. However, he quickly said, "You know me. I'm not a bad person. I just snapped."
The State's evidence showed that Lori had been struck 16 times, 6 in the head. Lt. Stiles, who found the bodies, testified that Lori had been struck so hard, her head was completely disfigured. She wasn't wearing a shirt, and her bra and maternity jeans were soaked with blood. Collin's little leg was sticking out from a garbage bag. Upon seeing it, Lt. Stiles said to the State Trooper with him, "We've got a baby here."
The 911 tape of Lori's call revealed the sound of heals clicking against a wood floor and Lori saying, "Stop it, Jimmy." Not having heard the tape, I cannot say what her tone was, but Collin was reportedly heard on the tape to say, "Run, Mommy."
It is hard to know what to think or believe. I find Jimmy's story to be mostly plausible, but questions remain. Why did he go back and bash Collin with a rock? And he had taken Lori's cell phone from her; why didn't he call 911 from that cell phone after Collin was shot? Why would he have gone inside to search in the basement for another phone? If he snapped, if it was self-defense, why did he then try to hide the bodies? Still, I don't know. Maybe it
was self-defense. Maybe he
did just snap. At this point, with my only knowledge of the case being that which has been reported in the local paper, I just don't know what to believe anymore.
I do feel more sorry for Jimmy now, though. I can't explain it. I just imagine him there, reliving the horror of it all, and my heart breaks for him. It breaks for his family. It breaks for Lori's family. It breaks for our community.
Really, I think that's what makes this all so difficult and heartbreaking. I think about everyone involved, and how hard this must be on them. There are the sheriff's deputies who were first on the scene. What must they have thought when they uncovered the bodies and had to arrest Jimmy, who surely they knew? And Jimmy's aunt and uncles -- I cannot imagine the physical anguish they felt at his confession to the murders. And Lori's parents must have been devastated to hear the news, remembering that only a few short hours before, they had sat down to lunch with Jimmy and Lori. How did this happen, and how do they recover from it? I'm pretty sure they can't.
Testimony will not resume until Monday. I imagine that by this time next week, there will be a verdict, and Jimmy's fate will be known. He stands accused of three counts of murder and two counts of concealing a deceased body. If I had to guess at this point, I would guess there will be some sort of compromise verdict. Some will want to convict him of first degree murder, others will want to acquit him or convict him of a far lesser charge. Perhaps they will compromise at a conviction of second degree murder for Lori and acquittal for the murders of her unborn child and Collin. In that case, he would face 40 years in prison and be eligible for parole in 10 years. No matter what, though, his life is over. I feel very sorry for him, but Lori's and Collin's lives are over, too. There has to be some justice for that.