When Donald Trump won the 2016 US presidential election, American Jews voted 70:30 against him. That didn’t stop the then leader of the UK Board of Deputies gushingly congratulating him “on behalf of British Jews”. It was a kick in the teeth to the American Jewish community. He was roundly criticised by many Jews here for his hasty and embarrassing action.
Two nights ago, the current Board of Deputies President, Marie van der Zyl praised Trump, saying, “he has increased peace in the Middle East”. In doing so, she aimed a similar kick at Israeli peace activists who regard the Abraham Accords (with human rights abusing Arab states) as based cynically on normalising the 53-year long illegal Israeli occupation.
Van der Zyl “balanced” her praise of Trump with a mealy-mouthed statement that he was divisive at home because “he has not sufficiently disavowed white supremacists”!
“…not sufficiently disavowed…” is an incredible understatement.
What is the truth? Donald Trump has emboldened white supremacists since he took office. He claimed that they included “fine people” after hundreds of them marched, chanting: “Jews will not replace us” at Charlotttesville in 2017; he has echoed their conspiracy theories, about the “great replacement”, frequently attacked George Soros, labelled refugees, Muslims, Mexicans, LGBT people as a threat to America, and called Black Lives Matter supporters “looters”, “lowlife” and “scum”.
Did Van der Zyl not listen to any of Trump’s words at his rally less than three weeks ago, just after he came out of hospital?
Using classic Far-Right conspiracy theory, he said Biden had “handed control to the socialist, the Marxist and left wing extremists”, and then said “Biden is also owned by the radical globalists, the wealthy donors, the big money, special interest, who shipped away your jobs, shut down your factories, threw open your borders and ravaged our cities, while sacrificing American blood and treasure in ridiculous endless wars.â
Who on earth does the Board of Deputies President imagine he is fingering here?
But it also begs some questions for the Labour Party’s new leadership who have placed so much trust in the political judgements of the Board of Deputies.
Do you agree with the Board of Deputies’ praise of Trump’s Middle East policy (which accords completely with Netanyahu’s)? Yes or No?
If you don’t agree with Marie Van der Zyl on this, is it not possible that other political assessments by the Board of Deputies might be very wrong-headed too?
Is it not time for Keir Starmer and Angela Rayner, more than six months after taking office, and after approaches to do so, to open a dialogue with the large number of Jewish members of the Labour Party who profoundly disagree with many of the Board of Deputiesâ political perspectives past and present (let alone those of the rabid right wingers of the âCampaign Against Antisemitismâ who motivated the EHRC investigation)?
In his Rosh Hashona (new year) message to the Jewish community Keir Starmer stated: âI have been proud to strengthen existing friendships whilst also establishing new ties right across the Jewish community and its organisationsâ (my emphasis). The first half of the statement is true, the second half is not.
Surely the time to open the dialogue to make that statement true is now, starting with Jewish Labour Party members and organisations who take a very different perspective to the Board of Deputies, the (unelected) Jewish Leadership Council and the Jewish Labour Movement.
It is also time he heard the voices of left -wing Jews, young and old, who are very active in anti-racist, anti-fascist and human rights work locally and globally, and the voices of Jews who advocate justice and equality for Palestinians, and support the Israeli anti-Occupation activists who share that perspective.
