(1) THE LONG GOODBYE. Two days after withdrawing his story from F&SF, Scott Edelman unexpectedly received an offer from Must Read Magazines (MRM) to accept his proposed contract revision. Edelman explains why he still turned them down in this addition to his recent post “A dream denied: My 54-year quest to publish a short story in F&SF”. The full quotes from his correspondence are available at the link. What follows is an excerpt:
POSTSCRIPT: Monday, November 17, 2025
When I hit publish on this post Wednesday, November 12th, I believed that marked the end of my journey. But to my great surprise, on the night of the 14th — two days after I withdrew my accepted F&SF story from publication as well as my Analog and Asimov’s stories from their respective queues, immediately submitting all three elsewhere — I received word from MRM they’d at last be willing to delete the word “alleged” from their indemnification clause in favor of “sustained,” substituting a variation on one of the samples I’d sent them…
…While I do give them credit for finally coming around to matching what every other short fiction market already offers, I decided I couldn’t be so selfish as to accept for myself what wasn’t also being offered to all writers published in MRM magazines. I decided the only way I’d allow their offered revision to be a win for me would be if I could somehow turn it into a win for you as well.
And so here is how I replied —
While I appreciate your willingness to finally incorporate a reasonable indemnification clause in my contract, our extensive back and forth gave me a distaste for the Must Read Magazine business model of not allowing the progress any individual writer has made toward reaching a fairer contract to accrue to all writers. That policy benefits those of us who have been around for awhile, are knowledgeable, and strong willed, while taking advantage of newer writers and those who don’t know any better.
And so the lesson I’ve taken from our intense negotiations — the first time in many years I couldn’t sign a contract as offered — is that I don’t want my byline in F&SF or any of the MRM magazines to send an incorrect message to my community that I’m OK with this, that all is well with your contracts, and therefore other writers should simply go ahead and sign them.
Which means at this point, I no longer feel comfortable signing a contract which only benefits me alone. As much as I’d love to be published in F&SF, I am not that selfish.
On the other hand, if going forward you were willing to remove the word “alleged” from *all* MRM contracts, so that indemnification clauses from now on only referenced “finally sustained,” I would consider that acceptable progress, and sign the contract. If not, let’s just go on as before, with the story withdrawn. …
…I hope you’ll see your way to taking my advice and incorporating my ongoing suggestion, because my community is more important to me than any single sale, even one which would fulfill a lifelong dream.
My suggestion didn’t achieve the goal I’d hoped for. What can I say? I’m not a diplomat, and I don’t think I truly believed they’d come around … but I had to give it a shot.
After that, there was further back and forth attempting to persuade me to set aside my greater goal and sign the contract, with an intimation that final offered change might someday be broadened to the boilerplate for others, but that could only be after further consultation with lawyers, insurance companies, and the SFWA contracts committee. There was even what I interpreted as an insinuation the MRM magazines could only survive if writers became more willing to sign contracts, as if I would be the cause of their eventual demise.
All of that added up to more than enough for me, and so tonight, I sent what I presume will be my final reply —
You’ve asked me to let you know what I’ve decided to do, and what I’ve decided to do is what has already been done. The story was withdrawn. The story remains withdrawn. Perhaps someday, with future changes to the basic boilerplate MRM contract, I could see myself being part of your stable of magazines … but not now….
…One last thing before I sign off — in a previous email, you attempted to blame the possible death of F&SF on me and other writers who wouldn’t sign your contracts in an act which felt like shaming and bullying. I found that both insulting and condescending, since the issue is and always has been not us, the writers, but the flawed MRM contract. I suggest you not use that tactic in the future when negotiating with others, as it backfired on me in a major way, making me even less likely to sign any MRM contract….
One writer who had hammered out their own individual contract with another MRM magazine, Analog, read Edelman’s postscript and was moved to withdraw the story. Marissa Lingen posted on Bluesky:


(2) GILLER PRIZE 2025. The 2025 Giller Prize winner was announced November 17. The Prize is a celebration of Canadian literary talent. From the descriptions posted to the award website it did not appear that the winner is a genre work:
- Souvankham Thammavongsa for her novel Pick a Colour, published by Knopf Canada
(3) MICHAEL A. BURSTEIN, WNBA FAN. If the women’s professional basketball franchise leaves Connecticut, sf writer Michael A. Burstein and his daughter hope it will stay in area. He hexpressed his sense of urgency to the Boston Globe:
When the Connecticut Sun announced in July plans to explore selling the team, longtime Brookline resident and science fiction writer Michael Burstein felt a sense of urgency.
He had become a WNBA fan and Sun season ticket-holder because his daughter Sheva was a fan. But a potential sale not only opened the door optimistically for a relocation to Boston, but it created a worst-case scenario that the Sun could leave New England entirely.
“It would be nice for the Sun to stay in Connecticut,” Burstein said. “But the thing I feel would be awful was if the Sun were moved out to Houston or somewhere out of New England, because right now the Sun is the only WNBA team for all of New England.”
With that in mind, the elected Brookline town meeting member and library trustee will introduce a resolution in support of the Boston City Council’s resolution to bring WNBA basketball to Boston.
Burstein said, “New England should have a WNBA team, full stop.”
The Sun had multiple suitors, including former Celtics owner Steve Pagliuca, who made a $325 million bid to bring the team to Boston, but progress stalled without league approval. The Sun will play the 2026 season in Connecticut.
“The question is what’s going to happen after that,” Burstein said.
Brookline’s town meeting occurs once a year — with a special meeting in the fall — but with cities lining up, Burstein said it was important to officially express Boston’s desire for a women’s basketball team.
“If the Sun had not made any announcements, if they were going to stay put, I’m pretty sure eventually through the process at some point the WNBA would expand into Boston,” he said. “But by announcing that they’re going to sell the team, possibly move the team away from New England, that makes it immediately more incumbent upon us to really push for the idea that a WNBA team should be in Boston. And that if the Sun is going to leave Connecticut, this is where they should go.”
Burstein told File 770: “Town Meeting starts tonight and the vote on this article will probably take place on Wednesday night. It’s expected to pass.”
Burstein has some WNBA fan photos on Instagram. Here’s one with Brittney Greiner. I can tell you I’m impressed.
(4) THE SUPERLATIVE, THE GREAT, AND THE MERELY BEST. A Deep Look by Dave Hook considers “What To make of J. G. Ballard’s Short Fiction”.
The Short: For complex reasons, I decided to read a subset of J. G. Ballard’s short speculative fiction. After reading 69 stories (just over half of his short works), my favorites are the superlative “The Cloud-Sculptors of Coral D“, a Vermilion Sands short story, F&SF December 1967, and “The Object of the Attack”, a short story, Interzone #9 Autumn 1984. 46 out of the other 67 were “Great”. I recommend reading the “superlative” and “great” works of Ballard’s short speculative fiction, see my recommendations below in science fiction, horror, fantasy and many very hard to classify stories. I also compare several Ballard “Best of” collections and The Complete Stories of J. G. Ballard….
(5) WHO WAS THAT UNMASKED MAN? At CrimeReads, Olivia Rutigliano asks “How Many Times in the Original Stories is Sherlock Holmes in Disguise?” I hope you were counting.
… As the adjectives in this roster suggest, Holmes does not merely use disguise to conceal his identity as a detective; he creates entirely new identities through numerous performative measures, designing characters to play for extended periods of time. Some of these characters are discarded after a day of surveillance; others are lived in for longer—Holmes proposes marriage to a woman while pretending to be the plumber in “Charles Augustus Milverton” and lives as the Irish American spy gathering intelligence for two years in the final Holmes story, “His Last Bow.”…
(6) PRAISE FOR LEIBER. Lev Grossman confesses, “When I was a child, the novels of Fritz Leiber were way more important to me than The Hobbit or The Lord of the Rings. If anything Tolkien was the British Leiber” in “That Other American Tolkien”.
… You would never mistake Leiber for anything other than a pulp writer—he’s not Shakespeare, or even Tolkien—but his prose is always smart and self-aware, so much so that I was shocked to learn that the first Fafhrd/Mouser story appeared in 1939, only two years after The Hobbit. He feels like the product of several generations of evolution past Tolkien…
(7) JEAN-LOUIS TRUDEL (1967-2025). Canadian sff writer Jean-Louis Trudel died November 17. Lloyd Penney reports, “He had spent time as a writer in residence in Vilnius, Lithuania, and was supposed to return to Canada on November 30. More details as they arise.”
When Trudel was inducted into the Canadian Science Fiction and Fantasy Hall of Fame (2021) his citation read:
Jean-Louis Trudel holds degrees in physics, astronomy, and the history and philosophy of science. Since 1994, he has authored (alone or in collaboration with Yves Meynard as Laurent McAllister) three science fiction novels published in France, four fiction collections, and twenty-six young adult books published in Canada…. He has received several literary distinctions, including the “Grand Prix de la Science-Fiction et du Fantastique québécois” in 2001 and several Prix Aurora Awards.
Trudel twice won Aurora Awards in fan categories, in 1994 and 1996.
(8) REBECCA HEINEMAN (1963-2025). “Gayming Icon and LGBTQ+ games pioneer, Rebecca Heineman, has died” reports Gayming Magazine.
Rebecca Heineman, a trailblazing figure in the video game industry and a celebrated icon within the LGBTQ+ gaming community, has died after being diagnosed with cancer only last month. Heineman was crowned Gayming Icon at this year’s Gayming Awards and we were honored that she flew into LA to spend time with her extended LGBTQ+ family and receive their plaudits for an inspiring career.
Rebecca Heineman was an icon in every sense of the word. She first made headlines in 1980 when she became the first-ever national video game champion by winning the Space Invaders tournament held by Atari. That victory kickstarted a career that would help shape the very foundation of modern video games.
As a self-taught programmer and designer, Rebecca helped port and develop some of the most iconic games of the ’80s, ’90s and ’00s. Her fingerprints are on classics like The Bard’s Tale 3: Thief of Fate, Wasteland, and Wolfenstein 3D, amongst several other iconic titles….
… But Rebecca’s legacy isn’t just about the games she made, it’s about the space she carved out for others. As an out and proud trans woman in the games industry, she was a trailblazer.
During her time at Amazon, she was the ‘Transgender Chair’ of Glamazon, Amazon’s LGBTQ+ staff group. She held similar positions at Microsoft’s GLEAM group and Sony’s LGBTQ+ advocacy group, the Sony Rainbow Coalition. Outside of the industry, she also advocated for LGBTQ+ people by holding a board position at GLAAD.
Her advocacy for LGBTQ+ inclusion, accessibility, and diversity in tech inspired countless developers and players. She didn’t just build games… she paved the way for future generations of LGBTQ+ developers to create games for years to come.
Heineman publicly came out as transgender in 2003, and was married to fellow games industry legend Jennell Jaquays. Jaquays sadly died of complications from Guillain–Barré syndrome in January 2024 and in her final post on social media, Rebecca poignantly spoke of with her….
(9) TODAY’S BIRTHDAY.
[Written by Paul Weimer.]
November 18, 1950 — Michael Swanwick, 75.
By Paul Weimer: I started off with Michael Swanwick’s work in the early 1990’s. That was a high time for science fantasy, where a mixing of science and fantasy that began in the late 1980’s was coming into final fruition. Swanwick’s The Iron Dragon’s Daughter, with an industrial age, mechanical dragons, and more, fitted my palate perfectly. It proved to be a bruising and uncompromising work, quite different than the more shiny science fantasy of, say, Mercedes Lackey’s Bedlam Bard series. (And the sequels to The Iron Dragon’s Daughter just reinforce that impression). I soon found Swanwick’s oeuvre to be weirder, and wilder than even that novel, with short stories, strange novels like Stations of the Tide to devour and much more.

I particularly like the Darger and Surplus stories and novels, set in a post apocalypse world where the two con artists (one of them a talking dog) make their way across Europe and get into misadventure after misadventure. There is a real vibrancy to the world, with post human intelligences, scheming dens of iniquity (and not just local potentates there, either) and a sense of fun and adventure on ever turn of their adventures that makes me think of a hellish version of the “Road to” movies, or perhaps Michael Chabon’s Gentlemen of the Road.
But even more than the rest of his wild and wooly oeuvre, I think of Swanwick for one, harsh, uncompromising story, and that is Radiant Doors. It is set in a near future where time-travelling refugees to the past are fleeing a terrible tyranny. Our main character, Virginia works at a refugee camp for them. When she gets a hold of a device from the future, the plot kicks off. The camp is a harsh, unforgiving place, and it, and the plot remind me a bit of an angry Harlan Ellison (especially in the description of the rat fighting). The last spoken sentence of dialogue, however, the capstone of the story, is an absolutely devastating blow that hits you with a gut punch. It encapsulates, in one sentence, the potency of Swanwick’s writing.
(10) COMICS SECTION.
- Arlo and Janis discuss Voyager.
- Dog Eat Doug fails the test.
- Moderately Confused knows the latest mystery.
- Mother Goose and Grimm leaves you wanting to know more.
(11) THIS YEAR’S HUGO WINNER CONTINUES. Rich Horton reviews “A Dark Drop of Delight” for Strange at Ecbatan.
A Drop of Corruption is the first sequel to The Tainted Cup, which won last year’s Hugo and World Fantasy awards for Best Novel. (This was an award I was generally happy with, as I found The Tainted Cup delightful, though it wasn’t my first choice for the Hugo.) A third volume, A Trade of Blood, is scheduled for 2026. I don’t know if the series will end there or continue — it is certainly the sort of series — essentially, a mystery series built around a rather Holmes/Watsonish pair — that could extend for quite some time. That said, there is a broader theme hinted at that may be resolved at some point, having to do with the nature of the Empire of Khanum, its history, its nearly immortal Emperor, and its uneasy reliance on “grafts” derived from the blood of the enormous sea creatures called leviathans….
(12) FLOAT PREVIEW. “Stranger Things Macy’s Thanksgiving Parade Float Has Demogorgon Puppet” says Variety.
Brendan Kennedy, director of creative production at Macy’s studio, has dried out from last year’s Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade after the festivities were dampened by persistent rain.
Come rain or shine, Kennedy, now on his second parade, is ready to “show off the floats and balloons that we’ve been working on for over a year.”
Aside from the traditional balloons and floats, Kennedy revealed Buzz Lightyear, Mario, Shrek and Pac-Man are among the new balloons. The phenomena that are KPop Demon Hunters and Labubu will also be represented during the parade.
However, Kennedy is most excited for the debut of the “Stranger Things” float. With the first installment of the fifth and final season dropping on Netflix the day before, the timing is perfect….
… The float will feature the Hawkins National Laboratory. “There’s a containment device meant to contain an eight and a half foot tall Demogorgon puppet,” he adds. “That size is really in the wheelhouse of parade and continuing the legacy of Tony Sarg’s puppetry in the parade.”
The float itself will feature practical effects, including lighting and smoke effects. “It’s the laboratory come to life.” Kennedy teases that there are easter eggs within the design of the float. In addition to that, Foreigner, whose music featured prominently in the show, will be performing on 34th Street….
Bleeding Cool has images.
(13) SMELL WORTHY OF TIM BURTON. Dr. Squatch gives us a chance to clean up our acts in time for the holidays with the “Nightmare Before Christmas: Season’s Creepings 4-Pack”.
Embrace the chaos of the holidays with a scary, merry combination of stink-defeating Skellington’s Suds and Oogie Boogie’s Brew! Whether you go with good or evil, dirt and grime will be gone for good!

(14) TRAILER PARK.
- “Fallout Season Two Official Trailer” from Prime Video.
Just about a month before you’re back in the Wasteland. About Fallout: Based on one of the greatest video games of all time, Fallout is the story of haves and have-nots in a world in which there’s almost nothing left to have. 200 years after the apocalypse, the gentle denizens of luxury fallout shelters are forced to return to the incredibly complex, gleefully weird and highly violent universe waiting for them above.
- “Monarch: Legacy of Monsters — Season 2 Date Announcement” from Apple TV.
Something new is lurking. Monarch: Legacy of Monsters Season 2 resurfaces on February 27. Based on the Monsterverse from Legendary, this dramatic saga — spanning three generations — reveals buried secrets and the ways that epic, earth-shattering events can reverberate through our lives.
[Thanks to Steven French, Kathy Sullivan Mike Kennedy, Michael A. Burstein, Lloyd Penney, Daniel Dern, Andrew Porter, John King Tarpinian, Chris Barkley, Cat Eldridge, SF Concatenation’s Jonathan Cowie, and Mark Roth-Whitworth for some of these stories. Title credit belongs to File 770 contributing editor of the day PJ Evans.]
















