慰安婦論38)ソ連兵への接待：満州黒川開拓団

『笑止千万、４５年余、軍事史を調べてきた私にとって、必ず、この様な御仁が登場して、あたかも全体の如く吹聴することは想定内であります。

先ずは、この方の軍歴を証していただきたい、
何処の連隊で、派遣先、移動先、従軍における戦闘地域と内容、出身地、
さて、具体的な慰安所の場所（地名）
慰安婦の国籍、慰安所の管理、慰安所の設置業者、慰安婦の稼ぎ、
慰安婦が稼いだ中から借金返済に何割充てていたか、

語っている内容に多くの作為が見られる、
冒頭の「逃げ遅れた中国人女性を兵舎に連れてきて慰安婦にした」
バカも休み休み言え！開いた口が塞がらない、

その兵舎は中隊規模か、大隊規模か、はたまた旅団規模か、連隊規模か、
※兵舎に連れてくることなど、１００パーセント出来ない、

歩哨が配置され、中国人の女性であれゲリラの危険性もあり
絶対にありえない。

さらに、性病検査と衛生状態の検査は、衛生兵が行うことではない！
嘘もたいがいにせい！

軍医の士気の下で行われる、この方どれほどの医学的知見を持っているかは甚だ疑わしいのと、軍医が行うべきことをなんで貴様がやれるのか！

全般に言えることは、この話の舞台が、昭和何年頃、何処で、どの様な作戦で その作戦の目的、日本軍の動員数、その作戦に費やした日数、その結果、日本軍の死傷者数、治療に当たった内容、

具体的な裏付けが、ひとつも無い。

加えて、衛生兵としての教育を受けた場所、期間、さらに、中国のどの地域に駐屯して、その地域特有の衛生環境で特に留意するように命じられた内容を述べてください。

この様ないい加減極まりない、信ぴょう性ゼロ（具体的な背景が無い）の妄言をBBCが取り上げるなど呆れ果てる、日本のメディアであれば、さもありなん。

最後に、慰安婦なる売春婦は日本人、朝鮮人、民間業者の募集によって
行われてきました、
その多くは、貧しい社会背景と戦時下でおこなわれてきたのです。

かっての大戦で慰安婦なる売春婦の存在が確認できない国はソ連のみ、
但し、ソ連軍の強姦、強奪、殺人については知る人ぞ知る、で、ございます。
多くの日本人が知らない、満州からの日本人避難民（婦女子と老人）の集団が、ソ連将兵に襲われ１２万人が命を落としている（終戦前後）

敬愛してやまない英国の国営放送BBCのチャンネルとは、にわかに信じがたい。

後期高齢者、元技術屋の端くれより。

LOL,
For me, as someone who has studied military history for more than 45 years, I can expect that such a person will always appear on the scene and talk as if it were the whole story.

Firstly, could you please provide evidence of this person's military career?
Specifically, I would like to know where in the regiment he served, where he was deployed, the areas of combat he served in and his role.
Where did he come from?
And the specific location of the comfort station?
Also, the nationality of the comfort women, how the comfort station was managed, who set up the comfort station and how much the comfort women earned?

What percentage of the comfort women's earnings was used to repay debts?

Much artifice can be seen in the content of the stories.
Take the opening sentence: 'Chinese women who failed to escape were brought to the barracks and made into comfort women.'
Give it a rest, you idiot! I can't keep my mouth shut.

Barracks may be company-, battalion-, brigade-, or regiment-sized.

It is one hundred per cent impossible to bring them into the barracks.

There are sentries posted, and there is a risk of guerrillas, whether they are Chinese women or not.
　It's absolutely impossible.

Furthermore, STD and hygiene inspections are not carried out by medics!
Don't lie to us!

What medical knowledge does this person have? How are these inspections carried out under the supervision of a military medical officer?
It is highly doubtful, and how can you do what a military doctor is supposed to do?
Can you tell me the year, location, and type of operation in the Showa period?

What was the purpose of the operation? How many Japanese troops were mobilised? How many days was the operation carried out over?
The number of Japanese casualties, and the treatment was provided as a result?

There is no concrete proof of any of this.

In addition, there is no information on where or for how long they were trained as medics or where in China they were stationed.

Please state where and for how long you received medical training, as well as where in China you were stationed and what specific sanitary measures you were instructed to take in that region.
Such a statement is extremely unreliable with no concrete background.

The BBC's coverage of these ludicrous statements with no concrete background is appalling. If it is the Japanese media, so be it.
Finally, the Japanese, Koreans, and private contractors have been recruiting comfort women prostitutes.

Japanese, Koreans, and private contractors.
Many of them were recruited from poor backgrounds during wartime.
The Soviet Union is the only country where the existence of comfort women in previous wars has not been confirmed.

However, the rape, robbery, and murder of Soviet troops are well known.
Many Japanese people are unaware that a group of Japanese refugees from Manchuria (consisting of women, girls, and elderly people) were attacked and killed by Soviet generals and the Soviet army.

Around 120,000 people lost their lives when the generals attacked (around the end of the war).

It is hard to believe that this is a programme on the respected British broadcaster, the BBC.
From a retired technical worker.